Full Coverage Savings Calculator

Know what full coverage costs, then save more. Adjust limits, add-ons, and claim frequency easily. See savings instantly, export results, and choose confidently now.

Calculator Inputs

Use realistic claim assumptions to estimate risk-adjusted savings.

Used for display only; calculations are numeric.
Example: 0.30 means one claim every ~3.3 years.
Used with deductible to estimate expected out-of-pocket.

Current Plan


Full Coverage Plan


Optional Add-ons (annual costs)

Selected add-ons are included in the full coverage plan by default.
Use this if your current plan already includes these add-ons.

Discounts (percent)

Discounts are stacked multiplicatively for a realistic effective rate.
Toggle if discounts are only available on one plan.

Advanced Analysis

NPV uses your discount rate; premiums grow by inflation rate.

Example Data Table

Sample scenarios help validate your expectations. Values shown are illustrative.

Scenario Current Monthly Full Coverage Monthly Expected Claims/Yr Est. Annual Savings
City commute 12,000 9,800 0.35 26,400
Low mileage 10,500 9,900 0.20 7,200
Higher deductible 13,200 10,400 0.40 33,600
Added add-ons 11,700 10,900 0.30 9,600
High risk profile 15,500 13,700 0.70 21,600
Tip: Use your own numbers to replace these samples.

Formula Used

This calculator estimates a risk-adjusted annual cost for each plan.

BaseAnnualPremium      = MonthlyPremium × 12
SelectedAddOns         = Σ(AddOnAnnualCost if selected)

EffectiveDiscount      = 1 − Π(1 − DiscountRate_i)

PremiumAfterDiscounts  = (BaseAnnualPremium + SelectedAddOns) × (1 − EffectiveDiscount)

TaxesAndFees           = PremiumAfterDiscounts × TaxRate

ExpectedOutOfPocket    = ClaimFrequency × min(AvgClaimAmount, Deductible)

RiskAdjustedAnnualCost =
  PremiumAfterDiscounts + TaxesAndFees + AdminFees + ExpectedOutOfPocket

AnnualSavings          = CurrentCost − FullCoverageCost

NPV Savings (horizon)  =
  Σ [ (Savings_y) / (1 + DiscountRate)^(y−1) ]
  where Savings_y grows with InflationRate
Break-even claims estimates how many claims per year would offset premium savings when the full coverage deductible is higher.

How to Use This Calculator

  1. Enter your current monthly premium, deductible, and any annual fees.
  2. Enter the full coverage quote, including deductible and taxes/fees.
  3. Select add-ons you plan to include, then set their annual costs.
  4. Set discounts and choose which plan they apply to.
  5. Estimate your claim frequency and average claim size realistically.
  6. Review results, then export CSV or PDF for comparison.

Coverage Cost Drivers

A difference of 1,000 in monthly premium equals 12,000 per year before taxes. Add-ons behave like fixed operating expenses because they repeat annually. When taxes and fees are 7.5%, every 100,000 of premium-after-discounts adds 7,500 to total cost. Admin fees are pure overhead; a 1,500 annual fee is the same as adding 125 monthly.

Deductible and Claim Risk

Expected out-of-pocket is modeled as claim frequency multiplied by the smaller of average claim and deductible. If frequency is 0.35 and the deductible is 25,000, the expected out-of-pocket is 8,750. If your average claim is below the deductible, most losses are treated as out-of-pocket, which is conservative for small repairs. Raising the deductible can reduce premiums, but it often increases the risk line. Doubling frequency doubles the estimate.

Discount Stacking Reality

Multiple discounts rarely add cleanly. This tool stacks them multiplicatively: 1 − Π(1 − di). For example, 10%, 5%, and 3% becomes 1 − (0.90 × 0.95 × 0.97) = 17.07%, not 18%. This reduces the chance of overstating savings on premiums. Use toggles if discounts apply only to one plan.

Savings and Break-even

Annual savings equals current risk-adjusted cost minus full coverage cost. Savings rate expresses the same result as a percentage of the current plan. Break-even claims estimates how many claims per year would erase premium-side savings when the full coverage deductible is higher. It divides premium-side savings by the deductible increase, so 10,000 of savings and a 5,000 deductible increase implies 2.00 break-even claims. Negative savings mean you pay more for protection.

Horizon and Present Value

Multi-year decisions should consider time value. The calculator projects both plans forward using a premium inflation rate, then discounts each year’s savings with your discount rate to estimate NPV. Over a 5-year horizon, a 6% inflation and 10% discount rate reduces the weight of distant years, so near-term savings dominate. Lower discount rates increase the importance of later years.

FAQs

1) What does “risk-adjusted annual cost” include?

It adds premium after discounts, taxes and fees, admin charges, and expected out-of-pocket. Expected out-of-pocket uses claim frequency and the smaller of average claim and deductible to estimate typical yearly exposure.

2) How do I choose a realistic claim frequency?

Start with your recent history, then smooth it over time. One claim in five years is 0.20. If you drive more, park on-street, or commute daily, consider a higher frequency and test sensitivity.

3) Why are discounts combined multiplicatively?

Discounts are usually applied sequentially on the remaining amount. Multiplicative stacking prevents overstating the effective rate. For example, 10% then 5% is 14.5%, not 15%.

4) Do add-ons apply to both plans in this tool?

Selected add-ons are included in the full coverage plan by default. If your current plan already includes them, enable “Also apply selected add-ons to current plan” to keep the comparison fair.

5) What does NPV savings tell me?

NPV converts future savings into today’s value using your discount rate. It helps compare options over multiple years, especially when premiums inflate. A positive NPV means the full coverage option is cheaper in present-value terms.

6) Can this calculator replace an insurer quotation?

No. It is an estimate tool for planning and comparison. Final pricing depends on underwriting, coverage limits, endorsements, taxes, and local rules. Always confirm with official policy documents and quoted premiums.

Related Calculators

Auto Insurance Discount CalculatorCar Insurance Coverage ComparisonLiability Insurance Quote CalculatorFull Coverage Insurance CalculatorComprehensive Coverage ComparisonCollision Insurance Savings CalculatorCar Insurance Rate EstimatorCar Insurance Cost EstimatorInsurance Savings Comparison ToolVehicle Coverage Quote Calculator

Important Note: All the Calculators listed in this site are for educational purpose only and we do not guarentee the accuracy of results. Please do consult with other sources as well.