Collision Insurance Savings Calculator

Tune your deductible to lower collision premiums today. Model claim risk, repairs, and ownership horizon. Get savings, breakeven points, and downloads in minutes securely.

Calculator
Enter your details to estimate collision savings.
Layout adapts: 3 columns large, 2 medium, 1 mobile.
Used only for display.
Upper bound for repair exposure when uninsured.
Use your last renewal statement if possible.
Amount you pay before coverage applies.
Higher deductible usually lowers premiums.
Use an average of past repairs or a best estimate.
Adjusted further by mileage, age, and history.
Used only when Claim risk is Custom.
Higher mileage can increase incident likelihood.
Used for a simple risk adjustment.
More claims‑free years reduces modeled probability.
Older vehicles can be more repair‑prone.
Used to compute net present value (NPV).
Models renewal increases across years.
Higher values reduce the weight of future costs.
How strongly premiums react to deductible changes.
If Yes, dropping collision is blocked.
Dropping increases exposure to repairs.
Total discount capped at 15%.
Reset
Example data table
Vehicle value Premium Deductible (current → new) Repair cost Claim risk Estimated annual savings
₨2,800,000 ₨65,000 ₨25,000 → ₨50,000 ₨180,000 Medium ₨9,000–₨18,000 (varies by inputs)
$18,000 $520 $500 → $1,000 $2,200 Low $45–$110 (varies by inputs)
Examples are illustrative and not insurer quotes.
Formula used
How to use this calculator
  1. Enter your current premium and deductible from your policy.
  2. Choose a new deductible or select dropping collision coverage.
  3. Set your claim risk and repair cost estimate for realistic results.
  4. Adjust horizon, premium growth, and discount rate for planning.
  5. Review expected savings, breakeven probabilities, and NPV.
  6. Download CSV or PDF for your records and comparisons.

Deductible Leverage

Raising the collision deductible often reduces the premium, but it shifts more expense to you during a claim. In the calculator, a move from 25,000 to 50,000 with a 65,000 annual premium and α=0.25 can lower the modeled premium by about 16% before discounts. The tool then compares the premium drop against the added deductible exposure.

Risk-Based Expected Cost

Expected out-of-pocket is computed as p(claim) × min(deductible, repair cost). With a medium base risk near 10%, a typical repair of 180,000 and a 25,000 deductible yields about 2,500 expected out-of-pocket per year. If the probability increases to 18% under high risk, the same inputs raise expected out-of-pocket to 4,500, shrinking premium-driven savings. Mileage, driver age, vehicle age, and claims-free years adjust p(claim), which is clamped between 1% and 40% to avoid unrealistic extremes.

Premium Elasticity and Discounts

The premium model uses Premium_new = Premium_current × (Ded_current/Ded_new)^α × (1−Discount). A 5%–15% safety discount can materially change results: at 10% discount, a 55,000 modeled premium becomes 49,500. Adjust α to match your market; values near 0.20–0.35 produce moderate sensitivity to deductible changes. Discounts from safety features are capped at 15% in the tool to reflect typical underwriting limits.

Breakeven Signals

Breakeven probability indicates when a strategy stops saving money. For deductible changes, it is PremiumSavings ÷ (min(D_new,Repair) − min(D_cur,Repair)). If breakeven is 22%, claims above 22% per year can erase expected savings. For dropping collision, breakeven is CurrentPremium ÷ (Repair − min(D_cur,Repair)). Use these thresholds to test “what-if” scenarios: if your realistic claim probability is far below breakeven, savings are more robust.

Planning with NPV

Multi-year decisions benefit from discounting. The calculator applies premium growth g and discount rate r to estimate net present value over 1–15 years. Example: with g=8% and r=10% across 4 years, near-term premiums weigh more than later premiums, so immediate premium savings matter most. Vehicle value caps repair exposure, aiding comparisons across older and newer cars. Use NPV savings to rank strategies consistently, more confidently.

FAQs

What does expected annual savings represent?

It is the difference between your current expected annual cost and the new strategy’s expected annual cost, combining premium plus modeled out-of-pocket based on claim probability.

How is claim probability estimated?

You choose a base level (low, medium, high, or custom). The calculator adjusts it using mileage, driver age, vehicle age, and claims‑free years, then limits the result to a 1%–40% range.

Why does changing the deductible affect the premium?

Premiums are modeled to fall as deductibles rise. The elasticity parameter α controls how strongly premiums respond to deductible changes, and safety discounts reduce the premium further.

When should I avoid dropping collision coverage?

If a lender requires it, the tool blocks this option. Even without a lender, dropping collision can be costly when repair costs are high relative to your budget or when your claim probability is elevated.

What is the breakeven probability?

It is the claim probability where premium savings are exactly offset by extra expected out-of-pocket. If your realistic probability is below breakeven, the strategy is more likely to save money.

What does NPV savings tell me?

NPV savings discounts future expected costs over your chosen horizon, applying premium growth and a discount rate. It helps compare strategies consistently when savings occur across multiple years.

Related Calculators

Auto Insurance Discount CalculatorCar Insurance Coverage ComparisonLiability Insurance Quote CalculatorFull Coverage Insurance CalculatorComprehensive Coverage ComparisonCar Insurance Rate EstimatorCar Insurance Cost EstimatorInsurance Savings Comparison ToolVehicle Coverage Quote CalculatorQuote Comparison Tool for Auto

Important Note: All the Calculators listed in this site are for educational purpose only and we do not guarentee the accuracy of results. Please do consult with other sources as well.